top of page

Gravitational Lens Confirms the Hubble Tension

New insights from supernova SN H0pe explore a puzzling cosmic mystery.

New insights from supernova SN H0pe explore a puzzling cosmic mystery.

Gravitational Lens Confirms the Hubble Tension

F. Schubert

F. Schubert

A humanist first, passionate about human interactions, AI, Space, Human Life and a DJ. 20 year experienced in Team Management in BBAS3 and also founder of Estudio1514.com. São Paulo, Brazil based.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Resumo

We have long accepted that the Universe is expanding. The foundational research that provided solid evidence for cosmic expansion came from Edwin Hubble in 1929. This pivotal work relied on observational data from Vesto Slipher, Milton Humason, and Henrietta Leavitt. Today, the rate of this cosmic expansion is referred to as the Hubble constant or Hubble parameter, denoted as H0. Understanding H0 is crucial because it enables us to calculate significant cosmic metrics, such as the age of the Universe since the Big Bang.

In the early periods of cosmological study, the estimates for the Hubble parameter displayed considerable variation. Hubble's original estimation clocked in around 500 (km/s)/Mpc. However, progress was gradual, and by the 1960s, the value stabilized between 50 and 90 (km/s)/Mpc, a range that persisted throughout much of the 20th century. Achieving precision remained challenging, primarily due to the limitations inherent in our measurement methods. These initial calculations employed the cosmic distance ladder—a technique that builds upon previous observations to estimate increasingly larger cosmic distances. As methodologies evolved, recent decades witnessed a more settled estimation around 70 (km/s)/Mpc. Yet, this tranquility was not to last.

Webb image showing the appearances of a lensed supernova. Credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI
Webb image showing the appearances of a lensed supernova. Credit: NASA, ESA, CSA, STScI

With advancements in technology, particularly through satellites like WMAP and Planck, astronomers began producing high-resolution images of the cosmic microwave background. Through fluctuations observed in this background radiation, a new method emerged for measuring H0, yielding values ranging from 67 to 68 (km/s)/Mpc. Conversely, other investigations focused on distant supernovae constrained the value to approximately 73 to 75 (km/s)/Mpc. While both approaches offered significant precision, they presented a stark contradiction. This disparity has come to be known as the Hubble tension problem, which stands as one of the most perplexing enigmas in modern cosmology.

The origins of this Hubble tension remain unclear. It could suggest that the observational techniques currently employed are fundamentally flawed, or it might signify that aspects of dark energy and cosmic expansion elude our understanding. A consensus among astronomers suggests that an effective means to explore this mystery involves seeking alternative methods for determining H0 that do not rely on either the cosmic background or the cosmic distance ladder. One promising avenue is gravitational lensing.

Gravitational lensing arises from the warping of space-time due to gravity, allowing light paths to bend around massive objects. For instance, when a distant galaxy lies behind a nearer galaxy, observers may witness a distorted view of the farther galaxy or even multiple representations of it. Notably, the phenomenon of multiple images comes into play; each image's light travels along a different path, leading to varying distances. Given that light travels at a finite speed, this variation allows us to observe the same celestial object across different timeframes.

While this effect might appear negligible for galaxies, it holds substantial significance for supernovae. Specifically, gravitational lensing enables repeated observations of the same supernova. By analyzing the differing paths of each supernova image, researchers can ascertain the relative distances involved. Furthermore, timing the emergence of each image provides insights into actual distances, facilitating a measurement approach independent of the cosmic distance ladder. Although this technique has been previously utilized, past studies yielded uncertainties too large to reconcile the Hubble tension. A recent investigation, however, appears to overcome those limitations.


The recent research centers around JWST images of a Type Ia supernova designated SN H0pe. Remarkably, it ranks among the most distant supernovae ever documented. Thanks to the proximity of the galaxy cluster G165, researchers successfully captured three lensed images of SN H0pe. By combining the timing, brightness data, and calculated light paths, the researchers estimated H0 to be in the range of 70 to 83 (km/s)/Mpc. Although carrying a higher uncertainty than some previous methods, these findings align closely with the typical distance ladder estimations while diverging from the values derived from cosmic microwave background observations.

Despite the intriguing results surrounding SN H0pe, the tension regarding H0 persists. Far from resolving the issue, this new finding underscores the complexities of cosmic expansion that continue to puzzle scientists. There remains an apparent gap in our understanding of this expansive journey, and it's evident that improved observational capabilities alone will not unravel the underlying mysteries of the universe.



Fonte

arXiv preprint

Tags

Hubble Tension, cosmic expansion, gravitational lensing, astronomy

You may also like

A Inteligência Artificial Replica-se: Um Marco Aterrorizante?

Lewandowski Intervém: Proíbe Algemas e Garante Voo da FAB para Deportados dos EUA

Trump Demite 17 Fiscais Independentes em Agências Governamentais dos EUA

Formas de Ganhar Dinheiro na Internet: 15 Ideias Promissoras para 2025

bottom of page